deviant art

Deviant Login Shop
 Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
Download Image
PNG, 1900×1519
more ▶

More from *Nyarmarr

Featured in Groups:

Details

September 12, 2012
3.0 MB
1900×1519
Sta.sh
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 26
Favourites: 962 [who?]

Views: 7,776 (0 today)
Downloads: 870 (0 today)
[x]
Add a Comment:
 
:iconroyalinblue:
This was a rather okay piece, not without problems, but certainly pretty good!

I liked the shading, it really did a good job of emphasizing her curves, and the background looks geed with it as well!

The texturing, too, was rather good, it liked the sky and the grass, you didn't skimp on the small details, something I like in a piece like this!

And now, to the inevitable nitpicks...

The legs, I noticed first off, were a bit long and thin, it seemed to just put me right off the thing. Not all the way, but this was such a good looking piece, I didn't much like seeing this.

The colors were a bit pale, and dull. It was a piece that seemed to be emotionless, is all.

The horn seemed a bit small for the rest of her, it just seemed to be sitting atop her head rather than being a part of it, and it sort of killed the piece for me.

The ears, in contrast, looked a bit thick for her, again, a bit of-putting. Sorry to come off as mean, but this was actually a rather good piece, and it had some clearly defined parts to improve on.

The shading looked a little rough, as in far too defined, with the rings looking a bit mechanical, maybe work on smoothing the edges out next time?

Another problem I had was the eyes, they were a bit too enlarged for her head, nicely detailed, but another thing that could have been fixed.

All in all, I rate this a solid 6.5/10, not terrible, pretty good actually, but it had some clearly defined areas of improvement, I actually did like this!
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
9 out of 10 deviants thought this was fair.

:iconnoert:
While perfectly fine techbically, it seems emotionally dead for me. The sunset, Twilight are really good in themselves but they just.. dont go together. Twiley's face lacks any emotion, just like she's sleepwalking, you could place her in space, mental facility or park without change of overall impression of the piece.
Emotion on Twily's face + more dynamic background (like rooftops or busy town square) for that pose would be perfect; and the sunset would be much better with something like Fluttershy or some romantic episode, or perhaps Apple family returning home from long trip

Still, a really good artwork, I can only dream to make something like that , keep up the good work ^_^
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
15 out of 16 deviants thought this was fair.

The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork

Please sign up or login to post a critique.

love 5 5 joy 2 2 wow 1 1 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconpsychosityc:
wow...this looks just sweet!
(i dont really wanna critique someone(cuz i cant make somethin as good as this), but her head and horn...is small)
still, great work! im like 10/10
Reply
:icondoughnutjoe:
"You can make it if you try
with a hop, skip and a jump!"

Don't forget to jump, Twi!
Reply
:iconltblackcoat:
all in all excellent, very good gradient from light to dark, the clouds are great, the ground area in the background is also great.

the fact her hoof (somewhat) covers the sun is a excellent touch.

the dignified pose is also a great touch.

the eye is excellent.

i feel there needs to be more violet (i think that's the right couler.) in her CM.

that the light source on her is unusual (somewhere at our "8") with no shine on her bridge from the setting sun.

the horn looks good but the line on it seems 2D (as if drawn on).

the viloet in her hair also seems a little pale.

personaly although there could be a good story behind it the hair seems uncharacteristic (messy and even unevenly cut.).

m the ears opening seems a little small.

her thigh seems a little thin.

i like her muzzle.

i do greatly enjoy the piece i feel in review that that the background is masterful, i recommend more focus on the foreground (it is not bad by no means merely great potential).

carry on the good work.
Reply
:iconcd749:
Stunning. Absolutely stunning :)
Reply
:iconcalaetmornie:
~CalaEtMornie Sep 14, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Twiley is my fave non Princess type MLP character!!!
Reply
:iconschneelocke:
Wonderful. One of the best Twilight pictures I've ever seen. :)
Reply
:icondocabsinthe:
*docabsinthe Sep 13, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Beautiful background and really nice unique pony style. faved :)
Reply
:iconmjbedi:
~MJBedi Sep 13, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Looks fantastic! The details and shading are very well done! :icontwilightlaplz:
Reply
:iconmadjackgatlinggun:
Wow! :omfg:

Very beautiful work!

:)
Reply
Add a Comment: